Hurricane Handyman Homeowners: fixed-price quotes to install, put up or take down shutters: fixed-price shutter quotes Post a job freeNeed storm help? Handymen & contractors: find local storm jobs: find local jobs Join freeFind jobs

Roll Down vs. Accordion Hurricane Shutters

Roll down vs accordion hurricane shutters: the short answer

Both are permanently mounted, close in seconds with nothing to carry or store, and both are approved for Florida's toughest wind zone. The difference is cost, convenience and looks.

  • Choose roll-down shutters if you want protection that hides in a box above the opening, can run on a motor, and doubles as year-round security and light control. They cost more, especially on windows.
  • Choose accordion shutters if you want the lowest-cost permanent shutter that you slide closed by hand and lock. They cost about 30% to 40% less on a typical window.

On big openings like sliding glass doors and lanais, the price gap nearly disappears. A 12-foot opening costs $3,115.84 as an accordion and $3,192.00 as a roll-down at our prices, as of November 2026.

Roll down vs accordion shutters side by side

Roll-down shutters Accordion shutters
How it works Aluminum slats roll down from a hood above the opening, along tracks on each side Folding aluminum blades slide closed from the sides, along a top and a bottom track
When open Hidden in the hood above the opening Stacked at the sides of the opening
How you close it Crank handle, motor, or by hand (63mm only) By hand, then lock
Motor option Yes, +$225, with a wall switch or remote No, our accordions are manual
Florida code approval HVHZ and non-HVHZ HVHZ and non-HVHZ
Other approvals TDI, IBC and IRC (TDI pending on the 63mm) TDI, IBC and IRC
Wind rating (design pressure) ±40 to ±200 PSF, by slat and size ±30 to ±205 PSF, by height
Maximum size Up to 286.5 inches wide (55mm) and 252 inches tall Any width; up to 192 inches tall
Locking Keyed lock on the bottom slat, an upgrade on manual shutters Keyed lock or egress turn lock, lockable from inside or outside
Light when closed Blocks light; 40mm and 55mm vented slats let some air and light through Optional clear windows in the shutter, $50 each
Colors White, Ivory, Beige, Bronze White, Ivory, Beige, Bronze
Price, 24 x 36 window From $586.80 $353.40
Price, 6-foot sliding door From $1,900.00 $1,343.44
Price, 12-foot opening From $3,192.00 $3,115.84
Lead time Generally 4 to 6 weeks Generally 4 to 6 weeks

Prices for one shutter on a concrete wall, as of November 2026. Roll-down prices are for the 63mm with a crank; accordion prices are with the standard lock and tracks.

Which is stronger, roll-down or accordion?

On paper, neither. The roll-down and accordion shutters we sell both meet the Florida Building Code for the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone (HVHZ), which covers Miami-Dade and Broward counties and is the strictest wind standard in the state. HVHZ approval means the shutter passed large-missile impact and cyclic wind-pressure testing. Both also meet Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) standards and the International Building and Residential Codes, except that TDI approval on the 63mm roll-down is still pending.

For roll-downs, each of our three slat sizes has its own maximum size and wind rating:

Roll-down slat Maximum width Maximum height Design pressure
40mm, double wall 192 inches 252 inches ±45 to ±120 PSF
55mm, double wall 286.5 inches 252 inches ±40 to ±200 PSF
63mm, single wall 241.5 inches 252 inches ±45 to ±150 PSF

The Bertha HV accordion we sell is rated differently. Its approval puts no limit on width: the blades simply continue across the opening. What it limits is the span, the height between the top and bottom tracks, and that depends on the wind load:

Design pressure Maximum span (height), wall mounted
±30 PSF 158 to 192 inches
±60 PSF 133 to 136 inches
±100 PSF 100 to 105 inches
±150 PSF 67 to 86 inches
±205 PSF 49 to 72 inches

The two figures in each row are the limits for wind pushing in and pulling out; the smaller one governs. On a wood-frame wall, accordions are limited to ±105 PSF.

Design pressure is the wind load, in pounds per square foot, that the shutter is rated to resist, pushing in and pulling out. For both types, the rating your shutter gets depends on its size: the bigger the span, the lower the pressure it's rated for. Your building department sets the design pressure your opening needs, based on your wind zone and your home. At the top of their ranges, the two are nearly identical: ±200 PSF for the 55mm roll-down and ±205 PSF for the accordion.

Approval is per product and per size, so before you order, confirm that the model and size you choose carry the approval your building department requires. If you live in Miami-Dade or Broward, choose an HVHZ-approved shutter either way.

Everyday use, looks and light

Closing them. Both close in seconds with no tools. An accordion slides closed across the opening and locks. A roll-down lowers with a 5-foot crank handle, a wall switch or remote, or, on the 63mm hand-lift model, by hand. With motors, you can close every roll-down in the house without stepping outside.

Power outages. Accordions don't need power. Every motorized roll-down we sell has a crank override, so you can wind it closed by hand when the power is out.

Looks. When open, a roll-down disappears into a hood above the opening; only the hood and the side tracks show. An accordion stays on the wall all year, stacked at the sides of the opening. You choose how it stacks: half to each side, 75/25, or 98% to one side, which helps when there's little wall space on one side.

Light and privacy. Closed, a roll-down blocks outside light and cuts outside noise, which makes it useful in bedrooms and media rooms all year, not just in storms. The 40mm and 55mm come with vented slats that let some air and light through. An accordion can have clear windows built in, $50 each, so a closed shutter doesn't leave the room dark.

Security. Both lock. Accordions offer a keyed lock or an egress turn lock, lockable from the inside or the outside. Manual roll-downs can be upgraded to a keyed lock on the bottom slat, and a closed roll-down is a solid barrier against break-ins.

Upkeep. Accordions need occasional washing, plus silicone spray on the rollers and locks. On a roll-down, keep the side tracks clean and clear; running a shutter against debris in the tracks can jam it. Replacement parts for both are on our website: accordion shutter parts and roll-down shutter parts.

Roll down vs accordion hurricane shutters price

Real prices for one shutter on a concrete wall, from our online pricing tools, as of November 2026:

Opening (width x height, inches) Accordion Roll-down 63mm Roll-down 40mm Roll-down 55mm
24 x 36 window $353.40 $586.80 $625.92 $733.50
36 x 48 window $557.37 $779.68 $797.40 $886.00
36 x 60 window $615.00 $941.16 $962.55 $1,069.50
48 x 60 window $799.80 $1,197.68 $1,224.90 $1,361.00
72 x 80 sliding glass door $1,343.44 $1,900.00 $2,000.00 $2,150.00
96 x 80 sliding glass door $1,768.20 $2,015.00 $2,275.00 $2,405.00
144 x 96 sliding glass door $3,115.84 $3,192.00 $3,648.00 $3,876.00

Accordion prices include the standard lock and tracks; clear windows add $50 each. Roll-down prices are for a manual shutter with a crank handle; a motor adds $225 per shutter.

Why the gap closes on big openings. Both are priced by the square foot, and the rate drops as the shutter gets bigger. On windows, the cheapest roll-down costs $44 to $60 a square foot against $30 to $38 for an accordion. Above about 100 square feet, both cost $28 a square foot.

For your exact price, run your opening through the roll-down pricing tool and the accordion pricing tool. For a full breakdown of roll-down prices, see how much roll down hurricane shutters cost.

Roll-down or accordion: which fits your home?

Roll-downs fit best when:

  • You'll close them often, for privacy, light control or security, not just for storms.
  • You want the shutters out of sight when they're open.
  • You want to close them with a switch, a remote, your phone or Alexa.
  • The openings are big, like sliding glass doors or a lanai, where the price is close to an accordion's.

Accordions fit best when:

  • Budget matters most, especially on windows.
  • You're happy to slide them closed by hand.
  • You want light to come through a closed shutter (with clear windows).
  • A bedroom needs an egress lock that opens from the inside.

You don't have to pick one for the whole house. You can put roll-downs on the sliding doors and lanai and accordions on the windows; every shutter is priced one opening at a time.

Roll down vs accordion shutters: FAQ

Are roll down shutters better than accordion shutters? Not stronger: the ones we sell carry the same Florida code approvals, including the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone. Roll-downs are more convenient, hide when open and can be motorized. Accordions cost less, especially on windows.

Which is cheaper, roll-down or accordion shutters? Accordions. On a 24 x 36 inch window, the cheapest roll-down costs 66% more ($586.80 vs $353.40). On a 12-foot opening, it costs only 2% more ($3,192.00 vs $3,115.84). Prices as of November 2026.

Can accordion shutters be motorized? We sell our accordions as manual shutters. If you want a motor, choose roll-downs.

Do roll down shutters block light? Yes, when closed. The 40mm and 55mm come with vented slats that let some air and light through. If you want daylight with the shutter closed, an accordion with clear windows does that better.

Do both work in a power outage? Yes. Accordions are always manual, and every motorized roll-down we sell has a crank override.

Are both approved for Miami-Dade and Broward? Yes. The roll-down and accordion shutters we sell both meet the Florida Building Code for the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone. Approval is per product and size, so confirm yours with your building department.

How long do they take to ship? Both generally ship in 4 to 6 weeks. Lead times vary with hurricane season.

Still comparing? See all six types of hurricane shutters, or read electric vs manual roll down hurricane shutters.

Found this guide helpful? Add Hurricane Shutters Wholesale as a preferred source on Google so you can find us faster!